Health plan sponsors must adopt best practices to proactively address potential risks and uphold their fiduciary duties. Several steps can be taken to avoid pitfalls and implement oversight. Fiduciary oversight is not just a regulatory requirement; it’s a fundamental responsibility to safeguard the interests of plan participants. Recent Department of Labor (DOL) investigations demonstrate the serious consequences of non-compliance and provide a roadmap for fiduciary success.
Strengthening Vendor Selection and Contract Management
It’s essential for self-insured health plans to conduct thorough vendor due diligence. This step comes before engaging a third-party administrator (TPA), pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) or any other service provider. Plan sponsors will want to evaluate their experience, financial stability, compliance record, and cybersecurity protocols. A comprehensive assessment ensures the vendor is well-equipped to meet the plan’s requirements while minimizing risks. A detailed review of contracts, fee structures, and performance guarantees can help prevent issues such as the unreasonable fees revealed in the 2024 Suffolk Administrative Services case. This level of scrutiny ensures that costs are transparent, reasonable, and aligned with the plan’s best interests, ultimately protecting plan assets from unnecessary expenditures.
Establishing clear and protective contracts is a cornerstone of effective vendor management. Agreements should include unambiguous fee structures, performance guarantees, and explicit liability for errors or breaches. Such clarity would have mitigated the risks associated with EmblemHealth’s 2023 case regarding cross-plan offsetting practices by explicitly prohibiting inappropriate fund usage and establishing strict controls on financial practices. Including termination clauses and indemnity provisions can further safeguard the plan, ensuring that the sponsor retains control and accountability over vendor activities.
Enhancing Oversight Through Monitoring and Technology
Regular monitoring of vendor performance is critical to maintaining compliance and ensuring service quality. Routine audits should be scheduled to evaluate claim accuracy, plan provision adherence and compliance with service-level agreements (SLAs). Leveraging benchmarking tools can help measure vendor performance against industry standards, identifying areas that require improvement. These proactive measures ensure that discrepancies or inefficiencies are detected and addressed before they escalate, promoting fair and consistent practices that protect the plan and its participants.
Plan sponsors can also leverage technology and data analytics to improve oversight. Advanced data analytics tools offer invaluable insights into claims processing, plan utilization and vendor performance. By identifying trends, anomalies and risks in real-time, these technologies can help prevent systemic issues, such as the misuse of plan assets in the Axim Fringe Benefit Group case with the DOL in 2024. Predictive analytics and machine learning can further bolster oversight by flagging potential vulnerabilities and enabling corrective actions before they lead to financial or reputational damage. Integrating such technologies is a forward-looking strategy that enhances transparency and strengthens fiduciary oversight.
Building Strong Vendor Relationships and Communication
Maintaining regular communication with vendors ensures alignment between their operations and the plan’s goals. Regularly scheduled meetings provide an opportunity to address emerging issues, clarify expectations, and refine processes. Establishing clear escalation procedures allows for quick resolution of disputes or errors, reducing disruption to plan participants. By fostering a collaborative relationship, plan sponsors can hold vendors accountable while ensuring that their activities support the overall fiduciary objectives of the plan.
Comprehensive Documentation
Finally, comprehensive documentation of all oversight activities is critical to demonstrating due diligence and protecting plan sponsors from potential liability. Detailed records of evaluations, audits, corrective actions, and communications serve as evidence of fiduciary responsibility and compliance with regulatory standards. This practice safeguards sponsors during DOL investigations or participant inquiries and builds stakeholder trust. Maintaining a robust audit trail ensures transparency, accountability and confidence in the plan’s governance.
Key Takeaways
By implementing these best practices, plan sponsors can minimize risk, enhance vendor accountability and fulfill their fiduciary responsibilities. These measures reduce the likelihood of costly errors or legal disputes, strengthen participant trust and ensure compliance with evolving regulatory standards.
Fiduciary oversight in the management of self-insured health plans is not just a regulatory expectation, it is a critical safeguard for participant benefits and the long-term viability of the plan. As illustrated by recent DOL enforcement actions, lapses in oversight can result in significant financial, legal, and reputational consequences. These real-world cases highlight the importance of proactive governance and serve as cautionary examples for all plan fiduciaries.
To mitigate these risks, plan sponsors must move beyond reactive compliance and instead adopt a structured approach grounded in best practices. From rigorous vendor due diligence and clear contract terms to ongoing performance monitoring, data-driven oversight, and robust documentation, each of these strategies reinforces the fiduciary’s duty to act in the best interest of plan participants.
By learning from past failures and embedding strong controls into daily operations, trustees and administrators can fulfill their obligations with confidence, ensuring not only regulatory compliance but also the delivery of high-quality, cost-effective benefits to those they serve.
Contact Us
To discuss our service offerings and how Withum can help, contact a member of our Self-Insured Health Plan Advisory Services Team.
