As attorneys navigate the complex landscape of tax law, understanding the financial intricacies of their practice is crucial. One area that demands attention is advanced client costs. These costs, often borne by attorneys on behalf of their clients, can significantly impact both financial reporting and overall profitability.
What Are Advanced Client Costs?
Attorneys, especially those working on a contingency basis, may advance costs and incur expenses on behalf of their clients. These expenses could include court filing fees, expert witness fees, travel expenses, and other disbursements related to legal proceedings. When attorneys use the cash basis method of accounting, they face important decisions regarding when to deduct these costs and how to handle recovered expenses.
The Cash Basis Dilemma
- Deducting Expenses When Paid: Under the cash basis method, attorneys typically deduct advanced client costs when they are actually paid. This approach aligns with the timing of cash flows but may distort income in the short term.
- Including Recovered Costs in Income: When clients reimburse attorneys for advanced costs, the recovered amounts are included in income upon receipt. However, this can create a mismatch between the timing of deductions and income recognition.
- Long-Term Implications: Legal cases can take years to resolve. Attorneys must carefully manage the timing of deductions and income recognition to accurately reflect their financial position.
The IRS Perspective
The Attorneys Audit Technique Guide issued by the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) sheds light on how these costs should be handled. Here are some key points:
- Recording Advanced Costs:
- Advanced costs are recorded into the system similarly to other accounts receivable.
- At the end of each month, the partner assigned to a particular case reviews the hours and other costs charged to the client.
- Treatment as Loans:
- Courts have ruled that costs paid on behalf of a client should be treated as loans for tax purposes.
- These costs are not deductible currently as business expenses.
- These types of costs are deemed to be those of the client, not of the attorney, because of expected repayment.
- Bad Debt Deduction:
- Regular reviews of outstanding advanced costs help identify uncollectible amounts, which can then be written off as bad debt.
- Cost Receivable vs. Deductible Expense:
- The IRS and the courts have generally allowed certain client costs to be currently deductible as “normal operating expenses,” which would be incurred even if not charged to a particular client.
- A current deduction would be allowed when incurred.
- When reimbursed by the client, the reimbursement would be picked up as income in the year of reimbursement.
- The type of costs included in this type of operating expenses are soft costs.
- Attorneys should carefully examine client costs to determine which costs are deductible, versus which are required to be reported on the law firm’s balance sheet as “advanced client costs.” Also, the status of each case should be reviewed to determine which cases have been lost (which would allow a bad debt deduction in the year the costs are deemed uncollectible).
- The IRS and the courts have generally allowed certain client costs to be currently deductible as “normal operating expenses,” which would be incurred even if not charged to a particular client.
Takeaways
Navigating the treatment of advanced client costs requires attention to detail and adherence to IRS guidelines. By understanding these rules, attorneys can ensure accurate financial reporting and compliance with tax regulations. Remember, while bananas may not be the preferred unit of measurement for legal expenses, the IRS certainly has its own way of peeling back the layers of complexity!
For more detailed information, you can refer to the official IRS Attorneys Audit Technique Guide.
Authors: Carmella Yaworski | [email protected] and Hal Margolit, CPA, Tax Principal | [email protected]
Contact Us
For more information on this topic, please contact a member of Withum’s Law Firm Services Team.
